Ingleside Village Pizza introduced Macon to hand-tossed, made-from-scratch dough in a neighborhood storefront, and that local-first approach still defines the city’s pizza identity. Independent pizzerias outnumber national chains in Bibb County by a wide margin, and the most popular spots all emphasize dough made on premises rather than shipped frozen. Macon Pizza Company on Zebulon Road, Fatty’s on Cherry Street, and Ingleside Village each press and stretch their own dough daily, a detail that regulars treat as a baseline expectation.
Geographically, pizza options cluster in three distinct pockets. Downtown along Cherry Street and Second Street draws the bar crowd and late-night slice seekers, especially after events at the Macon City Auditorium or the Capitol Theatre. The Ingleside neighborhood in midtown has built a following around its walkable residential vibe, where customers pick up pies on foot. North Macon along Zebulon Road and Arkwright Road caters to suburban takeout and delivery demand, with Macon Pizza Company and the recently relocated Fatty’s competing for that market. New York-style thin crust dominates the local preference, though Mercer Village Pizza near Mercer University has carved out a niche with scratch-made Neapolitan pies fired in a brick oven. A large specialty pizza at most independent Macon shops runs $18-$24, with lunch slices available at several downtown locations for $3-$5.
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurants in Macon, Georgia
Ingleside Village Pizza
Address: 2395 Ingleside Ave, Macon, GA 31204
Website: inglesidevillagepizza.com
Ingleside Village Pizza occupies a small storefront in the walkable Ingleside neighborhood of midtown Macon. Owner Tina Dickson runs the kitchen with a crew that makes all dough in-house daily, and nothing arrives frozen or pre-made. The menu covers pizzas, calzones, sub sandwiches, and a “sloppy” version of their breadsticks that comes loaded with extra garlic and melted butter. Reviewers consistently flag the white pizza, the Ultimate Village (a loaded specialty pie), and the brownies as standout items. Ingleside Village is dine-in and carry-out only, with delivery available through Uber Eats and Macon2Go. Hours run Wednesday through Sunday.
Fatty’s Pizza
Address: 587 Cherry St, Macon, GA 31201
Website: fattyspizzamacon.com
Fatty’s operates two Macon locations: the original on Cherry Street downtown and a recently relocated north Macon spot at 3955 Arkwright Road (formerly on Tom Hill Sr Blvd). The Cherry Street location sits in the heart of the downtown entertainment district with sidewalk seating. Specialty pies include The Big Kahuna (pineapple and ham), the Mother Klucker (chicken, bacon, ranch swirl), and The S.O.B. (Monterey Jack base with spinach, onion, and bacon). Wings come in eight sauce options, and the calzone menu offers a three-topping Chubby Cal and a five-topping Fat Cal. The Arkwright Road location scored 99/100 on its health inspection.
Macon Pizza Company
Address: 5978 Zebulon Rd, Macon, GA 31210
Website: maconpizzacompany.com
Macon Pizza Company serves the Zebulon Road corridor with NY-style pies, calzones, and a lineup of specialty items like Shark Bites (pepperoni-stuffed bites), pepper sticks, and a cheesecake calzone that wraps New York cheesecake and chocolate inside calzone dough. The restaurant runs a two-medium-pizza deal that regulars cite as one of the better values in the area. Online ordering through their website is straightforward, and the kitchen regularly beats its own quoted wait times. Macon Pizza Company partners with Slice for delivery alongside direct pickup.
Pizza Restaurants in Macon: Common Questions
What price range covers a pizza order in Macon, GA?
Large specialty pizzas at independent Macon shops typically cost between $18 and $24. A basic large cheese pizza runs closer to $14-$16. Lunch slices at downtown locations like Fatty’s go for $3-$5 each. Delivery through third-party apps adds $3-$6 in fees, so calling ahead for pickup saves a noticeable amount on a regular order.
Does Macon have any late-night pizza options?
Fatty’s on Cherry Street stays open late on weekends and benefits from its location in the downtown entertainment district near the Capitol Theatre and Hargray Capitol Theatre. Macon Pizza Company also keeps extended weekend hours on Zebulon Road. Most independent pizza shops close by 9 or 10 PM on weeknights, so late-night options thin out Monday through Thursday.
Is New York-style or Neapolitan pizza more common in Macon, GA?
New York-style thin crust dominates the local market. Macon Pizza Company, Fatty’s, and Johnny’s New York Style Pizza on Zebulon Road all serve NY-style pies as their core product. For Neapolitan, Mercer Village Pizza near Mercer University fires scratch-made dough in a brick oven, and Your Pie on Bass Road offers a customizable brick-oven format. The NY-style preference likely reflects the influence of transplants and the military community at nearby Robins Air Force Base.
How does Macon’s pizza scene compare to other Middle Georgia cities?
Macon has significantly more independent pizza options than Warner Robins, Perry, or Milledgeville, which rely more heavily on national chains. The concentration of locally owned shops along Cherry Street, Ingleside, and Zebulon Road gives Bibb County a pizza variety that smaller surrounding cities lack. Warner Robins adds a few independent spots of its own, but Macon remains the clear hub for the region.
Do Macon pizza restaurants handle catering for large events?
Several do. Macon Pizza Company offers large-order packages through its website, and Fatty’s handles group orders for office and event catering from both locations. Mercer Village Pizza promotes catering specifically for campus and corporate events in the Mercer University area. For very large gatherings, calling 48 hours ahead is standard practice at most Macon pizza shops to ensure enough dough is prepped.